The Guardian March 31, 2004


Tackling the asbestos "cowboys"

Failure by authorities to police safety in the asbestos 
removal industry is threatening the lives of construction workers 
and members of the public. Last month members of the Construction 
Forestry Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU) called for the re-
establishment of NSW WorkCover's specialist Asbestos Demolition 
Units.

"These units should never have been closed down", said CFMEU 
State Secretary Andrew Ferguson. "These units had specialist 
inspectors. They were experts. Since the closure of the units 
safety has deteriorated."

This was shown at the beginning of the month at St Peters, in 
Sydney's inner west, when a developer conducted unlicensed 
demolition next door to a public school. Concerned parents 
contacted the CFMEU after material from the demolition spilt into 
the street.

The site, which was unsecured and allowed children to "play" on 
it after hours, contained asbestos components.

A WorkCover inspector who attended the site was allegedly 
threatened by the developer.

"The CFMEU has been very militant in its view of protection of 
the public", CFMEU organiser Marty Wyer said.

Illegal dumping

He pointed to the problem of demolition cowboys who illegally 
dump asbestos into landfill as a cost cutting measure. This was 
recently highlighted with asbestos being found on a popular beach 
in northern Sydney.

"There are cowboys in the industry", said Mr Wyer. "You only have 
to pick up a copy of your local rag and see the demolition 
companies that advertise in the classifieds. They may be able to 
quote a demolition licence, but this doesn't mean they can remove 
asbestos."

More dangerous

Mr Wyer spoke of demolition contractors who would remove asbestos 
on weekends to avoid scrutiny, crushing the asbestos up and 
rendering it more dangerous. The union says that educating people 
about the deadly dangers of asbestos is also a problem.

"My job is to empower safety representatives. It's easy to 
explain safety if it's a harness to stop someone falling off a 
roof. But because it can take 20 years to take effect we tend to 
think we're bullet-proof, but death from asbestos is a very 
horrible death", said Mr Wyer.

The move by the industry to clean up the cowboys operating in it 
follows complaints by residents in Randwick and Centennial Park, 
in Sydney's eastern suburbs, about the practices of asbestos 
removalists.

At the Centennial Park site, next to Fox Studios, residents were 
concerned about dust blowing across the street into their homes 
from an asbestos removal job. 

"We were given no warning", said local resident Josephine Wadlow-
Evans. "Residents were absolutely horrified."

Ms Wadlow-Evans and other residents allege that workers on the 
site were initially working without masks, asbestos sheeting was 
being dropped and broken and dust was blowing across the street 
into residents' homes, driven by "gale force winds".

Residents immediately contacted WorkCover but, despite their 
concerns, a WorkCover complaint register from the time notes that 
the incident "Does not warrant investigation as the company is 
licensed to conduct this work and has in the past demonstrated 
competency in same"!

From January 1 this year, the last loopholes allowing the use of 
asbestos were eliminated, but that does not address the problem 
of the asbestos that already exists in buildings across the 
country.

The deadly fibre was a popular building material for decades. As 
a result it is found in buildings ranging from the Opera House 
right across to local primary schools.

Forty-five thousand people are expected to die from asbestos 
related illness over the next 20 years unless effective medical 
treatments are found.

The extent of the problem can be measured by the existence now of 
8000 mesothelioma sufferers, 25,000 lung cancer patients with 
asbestos exposure and 33,000 asbestosis sufferers in Australia.

Peggy Trompf from the Workers' Health Centre in Lidcombe stresses 
the importance of dealing correctly with asbestos.

Domestic asbestos

"In a domestic situation asbestos is commonly found as fibro 
asbestos-cement sheeting [also known as AC Sheeting] in homes 
built pre-the 1970s, also as asbestos lagging or roof 
insulation", says Ms Trompf. "If there's more than 200 square 
metres of AC Sheeting, or any amount of lagging or insulation, it 
must be removed by a licensed contractor.

"In a commercial setting a thorough audit should be done to 
determine levels of asbestos and an asbestos register established 
before any work commences on any strip-out or demolition."

Peggy Trompf says that people who suspect that they may have 
asbestos in their home or workplace can contact the Workers' 
Health Centre and arrange to have materials tested. The Workers' 
Health Centre website also has a fact sheet on asbestos.

WorkCover NSW can be contacted for a list of licensed asbestos 
removal contractors.

Members of the public contact the CFMEU on 02 9267 3393 or the 
NSW WorkCover Demolition and Asbestos Hotline on 02 9370 5885, 02 
9370 5881 or 02 9370 9220 to report any suspicious behaviour on 
demolition sites.

Back to index page