The Guardian December 8, 1999


Britain:
Rail safety crisis

by Steve Metcalf*

Threats against union reps have become two-a-penny since rail maintenance 
was privatised in April 1996. My bosses recently lost an Industrial 
Tribunal case after they tried to stop me attending a union Health and 
Safety course.

They are also trying to stop statutory three-monthly safety inspections 
despite warnings that they may be about to break the law. They have also 
arbitrarily changed how track patrols to detect faults are done, despite 
our protests.

Nobody with any decency or intelligence thinks privatisation has done 
anything but compromise the safety of both staff and travelling public on 
the rail system.

The one hundred plus contracted rail companies stand open and vulnerable to 
the present government.

A recent (British) Guardian poll showed over 70 per cent of people 
want the railways re-nationalised, yet the Transport Minister, Prescott, 
seems to be allowing the cowboys to buy time until the outrage [over recent 
accidents] blows over.

Companies like Tarmac, which got involved in the Tory rail sell-off in 
order to make a quick killing, have also got involved in a situation where 
they may contribute to real killings.

Statistics show Tarmac has had to pay out more in recent compensation 
claims to people killed and injured in its service than other companies of 
its type.

Rail's crisis is not unique. The dogmatic drive for profit at any price 
proceeds apace world wide. Nor are these problems new.

A footnote in volume 1 of Karl Marx's Capital says: "Reynolds 
Newspaper January 1866 — Every week this same paper has, under the 
sensational headings, `Fearful and fatal accidents', `Appalling tragedies' 
&c, a whole list of fresh railway catastrophies."

In the main text Marx says of this: "In London three railwaymen — a guard, 
an engine driver and a signalman — are up before a coroner's jury.

"A tremendous railway accident has despatched hundreds of passengers into 
the next world. The negligence of the railway workers is the cause of the 
misfortune.

"They declare with one voice before the jury that ten or twelve years 
before, their labour lasted only eight hours a day. During the last five or 
six years, they say, it has been screwed up to 14, 18, and 20 hours, and 
under a specially severe pressure of holiday-makers, at times of excursion 
trains, it often lasted for 40 or 50 hours without a break.

"They were ordinary men, not Cyclops. At a certain point their labour-power 
failed. Torpor seized them. Their brain ceased to think, their eyes to see.

"The thoroughly `respectable' British jurymen answered by a verdict that 
sent them to the next assizes on a charge of manslaughter, and, in a gentle 
`rider' to their verdict, expressed the pious hope that the capitalist 
magnates of the railway would, in future, be more extravagant in the 
purchase of a sufficient quantity of labour-power, and more `abstemious', 
more `self-denying', more `thrifty' in the draining of paid labour-power."

Sound familiar? The "capitalist railway magnates" are back again today. 
They cut staff, connive at increasing hours worked, cut corners to meet 
"targets" and impress share owners. And they do it with an "acceptable 
risk" outlook also — risk to others, not themselves.

We workers must stop them, forever, we must take everything off them, with 
no compensation, and run things right, for the benefit of everyone.

*Steve Metcalf is a British Labour Party member, Regional Councillor of the 
RMT rail union, and Safety Rep for RMT members maintaining Britain's West 
Coast Mainline.

* * *
New Worker

Back to index page