The Guardian February 13, 2002


The "Trial" of Slobodan Milosevic:
"We've been lied to once again"

by Jared Israel*

The so-called "trial" of Slobodan Milosevic is supposed to open in The 
Hague on Tuesday, February 12. This NATO "court" has already been 
thoroughly discredited and is illegal. Just read "Illegal Tribunal — 
illegal indictment" by Dr Hans Koechler, the highly respected UN 
consultant.(1)

During the illegal NATO bombing of Yugoslavia, US Secretary of State 
Madeleine Albright openly demanded that "Tribunal" "Prosecutor" Louise 
Arbour indict Milosevic. The purpose: to criminalise the Yugoslav leader, 
thus heading off any possibility that wavering NATO governments would meet 
with him.(2)

During the NATO bombing [of Yugoslavia] NATO spokesman Jamie Shea boasted 
that the "Tribunal" would never indict NATO leaders because NATO controls 
it financially.(3)

In fact Milosevic has been on trial continuously in the Western media for 
14 years. Undoubtedly many have been persuaded by this media campaign and 
the supporting chorus — including some left-wing intellectuals — that 
Milosevic is guilty.

The only thing wrong with this trial-by-media is that the defence never got 
to speak and the prosecution lies.

Unlike Afghanistan and September 11, few people challenged the lies in the 
case of Yugoslavia; so they sank in. Worse, respected critics of US foreign 
policy uncritically accepted the basic premises of Western policy. It is 
unfortunate, but it is true.

Starting in 1987, when Milosevic led the campaign to throw pro-NATO 
elements out of the Yugoslav League of Communists, Washington pegged him as 
a "bad Indian". Politicians and the media attacked relentlessly, accusing 
him of fomenting fascist deeds by spouting racist demagoguery.

This race-hate charge is the key because if Milosevic had in fact organised 
the Serbs the way Hitler organised the Germans, he would have had to do it 
publicly. You can't promote hatred without promoting hatred.

Therefore we can check the accuracy of the anti-Serb, anti-Milosevic 
campaign by reading what Milosevic wrote. That is, by first reading what he 
wrote and then, to check the accuracy, reading what politicians and the 
media say he wrote.

I want to ask you to try a little experiment. Below is an excerpt from 
Milosevic's most famous speech, delivered in 1989 at Kosovo Field.

Now before you go and read it, please make a few predictions. He's going to 
talk about nationalism and about the relations between Serbs and other 
groups in Serbia. Kosovo was/is legally a province of Serbia, so that 
includes ethnic Albanians. What is he going to say?

Here's Milosevic:

"Serbia has never had only Serbs living in it. Today, more than in the 
past, members of other peoples and nationalities also live in it. This is 
not a disadvantage for Serbia. I am truly convinced that it is its 
advantage.

"National composition of almost all countries in the world today, 
particularly developed ones, has also been changing in this direction. 
Citizens of different nationalities, religions, and races have been living 
together more and more frequently and more and more successfully.

"Socialism in particular, being a progressive and just democratic society, 
should not allow people to be divided in the national and religious 
respect.

"The only differences one can and should allow in socialism are between 
hard working people and idlers and between honest people and dishonest 
people. Therefore, all people in Serbia who live from their own work, 
honestly, respecting other people and other nations, are in their own 
republic."

"Dramatic national divisions"

"After all, our entire country should be set up on the basis of such 
principles. Yugoslavia is a multinational community and it can survive only 
under the conditions of full equality for all nations that live in it.

"The crisis that hit Yugoslavia has brought about national divisions, but 
also social, cultural, religious and many other less important ones.

Among all these divisions, nationalist ones have shown themselves to be the 
most dramatic. Resolving them will make it easier to remove other divisions 
and mitigate the consequences they have created.

"For as long as multinational communities have existed, their weak point 
has always been the relations between different nations. The threat is that 
the question of one nation being endangered by the others can be posed one 
day and this can then start a wave of suspicions, accusations, and 
intolerance, a wave that invariably grows and is difficult to stop.

"This threat has been hanging like a sword over our heads all the time. 
Internal and external enemies of multi-national communities are aware of 
this and therefore they organise their activity against multinational 
societies mostly by fomenting national conflicts.

"At this moment, we in Yugoslavia are behaving as if we have never had such 
an experience and as if in our recent and distant past we have never 
experienced the worst tragedy of national conflicts that a society can 
experience and still survive."

[From Milosevic's Speech at Kosovo Field, June 28, 1989. Emperor's Clothes 
has posted two Western translations. This is the one made by the US 
Government. The other was made by the BBC.]

These words of Milosevic are never quoted.

Western politicians and the media have either a) lied about Milosevic or b) 
parroted those lies through naivete, servility or corruption.

Here is Robin Cooke, [British Foreign Minister] "commenting" on 
(supposedly) that speech. I cannot say whether Cooke is a liar or a parrot.

"Milosevic used this important anniversary not to give a message of hope 
and reform. Instead, he threatened force to deal with Yugoslavia's internal 
political difficulties.

"Doing so thereby launched his personal agenda of power and ethnic hatred 
under the cloak of nationalism. All the peoples of the region have suffered 
grievously ever since." (Cooke can be read in full at 

http://www.fco.gov.uk/news/newstext.asp?2597— until they take it down...)

Isn't that amazing? The man simply, brazenly lies. But it works — it works 
because nobody — nobody! — reading Cooke's words had ever seen the 
Milosevic speech. It's not in books. We searched Lexis and found a BBC 
translation from 1989 and the Orlando Sentinel. When we first hunted for 
it, we didn't have Lexis, so it took days to find it on microfilm in the 
library.

If you had read Cooke without reading Milosevic, wouldn't you have thought, 
"Maybe Cooke is exaggerating but there must be some truth to it." But in 
fact it was just a lie told to justify the destruction of Yugoslavia. There 
are now a million refugees living in Serbia, victims of that lie.

Legend and truth

Or consider the following excerpt. Here Milosevic talks about the famous 
Kosovo battle of 1389 which marked the onset of the long Ottoman occupation 
of his nation.

We have been told that Milosevic and the Serbs treat this battle with a 
Hitlerian folk-mystique. You know, super-macho, worship blood and gore. Or 
else with brooding self-pity, hatred and a lust for ethnic revenge.

Here is Milosevic:

"Today, it is difficult to say what is the historical truth about the 
Battle of Kosovo and what is legend. Today this is no longer important. 
Oppressed by pain and filled with hope, the people used to remember and to 
forget, as, after all, all people in the world do, and it was ashamed of 
treachery and glorified heroism.

"Therefore it is difficult to say today whether the Battle of Kosovo was a 
defeat or a victory for the Serbian people, whether thanks to it we fell 
into slavery or [whether thanks to it] we survived in this slavery.

"The answers to those questions will be constantly sought by science and 
the people. What has been certain through all the centuries until our time 
today is that disharmony struck Kosovo 600 years ago.

"If we lost the battle, then this was not only the result of social 
superiority and the armed advantage of the Ottoman Empire but also of the 
tragic disunity in the leadership of the Serbian state at that time. In 
that distant 1389, the Ottoman Empire was not only stronger than that of 
the Serbs but it was also more fortunate than the Serbian kingdom.

"The lack of unity and betrayal in Kosovo will continue to follow the 
Serbian people like an evil fate through the whole of its history. Even in 
the last war, this lack of unity and betrayal led the Serbian people and 
Serbia into agony, the consequences of which in the historical and moral 
sense exceeded fascist aggression."

Not only is this not fascist, it is downright thoughtful. No; more; it is 
lyrical. It has, for want of a better word, soul. It has that depth of 
feeling you sometimes find among people who have suffered greatly.

The Irish in Ireland have it. My grandparents, who were East European Jews, 
had it. Black people in the US have it. The Hutus in Africa have it. And 
sometimes, just sometimes, even the leaders of oppressed people have it. 
Lumumba had it. Martin Luther King had it. By the end of the US Civil War, 
Abe Lincoln had it.

But can you imagine George Bush saying anything as moving. as this:

"Oppressed by pain and filled with hope, the people used to remember and to 
forget, as, after all, all people in the world do, and it was ashamed of 
treachery and glorified heroism. Therefore it is difficult to say today 
whether the Battle of Kosovo was a defeat or a victory for the Serbian 
people, whether thanks to it we fell into slavery or [whether thanks to it] 
we survived in this slavery."

"As after all, all people in the world do." There is even a certain 
generosity of spirit here. And this is the man whom crude liars like Bush 
and Clinton have caricatured; perhaps they were just looking in the mirror 
and casting him in their own true image.

Milosevic and the Serbian people have been ruthlessly — and once you know 
the truth — outrageously lied about.

* * *
Further reading: 1) Illegal Tribunal — Illegal Indictment, by Dr. Hans Koechler at http://emperors-clothes.com/docs/prog2.htm 2) How Madeline Albright ordered The Hague "Tribunal" to "Indict" Milosevic at http://www.icdsm.org/more/lovie.htm 3) Official Statements Prove Hague "Tribunal" Belongs to NATO by Jared Israel at http://www.icdsm.org/more/belongs.htm Join Emperor's Clothes email list at http://emperors-clothes.com/f.htm and receive about one article per day. *Jared Israel is the editor of Emperor's Clothes.

Back to index page