Communist Party of Australia  


The Guardian

Current Issue

PDF Archive

Web Archive

Pete's Corner


Press Fund


About Us

Why you should ...

CPA introduction

Contact Us

facebook, twitter

Major Issues





Climate Change



What's On






Books, T-shirts, CDs/DVDs, Badges, Misc


Issue #1679      April 1, 2015

Film review by Ed Rampell

Queen & Country

In the extremely enjoyable Queen & Country legendary English director John Boorman treads familiar ground we’ve seen in various films wherein recruits are in conflict not so much with the enemy du jour but the military brass. Queen is far lighter than Fred Zinnemann’s 1953 From Here to Eternity and Stanley Kubrick’s 1987 Vietnam antiwar classic Full Metal Jacket. Like Robert Altman’s 1970 MASH, it is a humorous movie set during the Korean War era.

Callum Turner as Bill Rohan in Queen & Country.

In addition, Queen has the wink-wink nods some filmmakers lovingly include, referencing movies in order to give shout-outs to their cinematic influences and roots. Queen’s characters quote Bogie in 1942’s Casablanca, Clifton Webb saying, “Murder is my favourite crime” in 1944’s Laura, 1950’s Sunset Boulevard, Hitchcock flicks and so on. Boorman even visually quotes from one of his own most popular pictures, 1972’s Deliverance, with a river scene, wherein he also seems to cite Dziga Vertov’s 1929 masterpiece The Man with the Movie Camera.

These insider asides are, in particular, found in French films, especially in François Truffaut’s oeuvre. Indeed, with Queen’s semi-autobiographical allusions to anti-regimentation by regiments as well as to motion pictures, it reminded this film historian of Truffaut’s wonderful 1968 Stolen Kisses, wherein his screen self, Antoine Doinel (Jean-Pierre Léaud), is in or leaving France’s armed forces.

Having said this, just because Queen’s themes and sensibility may be familiar, it doesn’t mean that I have contempt for them. Rather, I welcome both as old friends – movie historians can never get enough of those in-the-know moving picture citations. (It makes us feel smug that we “get it.”) Plus, American and UK audiences – whose governments are endlessly at war with the world, invading this or that non-offending nation whose natural resources and the like are coveted by their ruling classes – can never get enough anti-militaristic, anti-authoritarian messages.

Indeed, Queen opened in LA right after the Academy Awards beat back the threat of conferring Oscar’s imprimatur upon Rory Kennedy’s odious “mockumentary” Last Days in Vietnam and on Clint Eastwood’s American Sniper, which celebrates the psychopathology of unprovoked invasions of nations under false pretexts that did us no harm – and the atrocity of picking off 160 human beings trying to defend their country from foreign intruders who have absolutely no right being there.

In this sequel of sorts, Queen follows the writer/director’s alter ego, Bill Rohan, the child growing up during the Battle of Britain in Boorman’s 1987 Hope and Glory. A decade or so later, His/Her Majesty has embroiled the UK in the latest of those perpetual wars Britain is forever fighting, this time in Asia, which the grown-up Bill (Callum Turner, who appears in the latest screen iterations of the literary classics Frankenstein in 2015 and the 2016 mini-series War and Peace) has been drafted to fight. However, unlike MASH, Queen’s action takes place on the home front, not in embattled Korea. (So presumably the BBC and the picture’s other producers need not worried about being hacked by Kim Jong-Un, LOL.)

The comic coming of age of Bill and his fellow conscript Percy Hapgood (Caleb Landry Jones) is complicated by being draftees and having to contend with military rules, regulations and officers. In particular, they go up against Sargent Major Bradley, expertly portrayed by David Thewlis as one of those clueless, humourless, by-the-book, ramrod-up-the-rear-end, mirthless, mindless militaristic martinets. Richard Grant likewise excels as the aptly named Major Cross.

There are the usual hijinks and pranks committed by irrepressible youth, aimed at deflating authority figures and the hierarchy of power relations, as the irreverent conscripts confront brigadiers, brigades, the brig and court martials and, in general, question the Cold War. During their leaves Bill and Percy pursue sexcapades, go to the movies – Bill and his girl Ophelia (Tamsin Egerton portrays the Oxford-attending blonde who is out of Bill’s league) watch Akira Kurosawa’s Rashomon – and the like. Bill lives in an islet in the River Thames near Shepperton Studios and watches movies being made – which could account for Boorman’s choice of avocations.

If so, we lucky moviegoers are the better for it. Boorman’s credits are too long to list in their entirety, but highlights include the stylish 1967 thriller Point Blank and 1968’s pacifistic Hell in the Pacific. Both starred Lee Marvin; the latter was shot at one of Palau’s Rock Islands, and every Palauan of a certain age has their favourite Lee Marvin story, which usually involves lots of drinking and carousing. In any case, Hell co-starred Toshiro Mifune (who is glimpsed in Queen during the abovementioned Rashomon sequence – a sly tip of the homage hat, if ever there was one!) who is stranded on a tiny island with Marvin during WW2, and was seen as an anti-Vietnam War allegory.

Boorman went on to helm the 1972 Deliverance (which could have been subtitled “The Hillbillies are Alive with the Sound of Snorting”) with Burt Reynolds, Jon Voight and who can ever forget a desperate Ned Beatty, grunting like a pig? 1985’s The Emerald Forest likewise had an environmental theme – although its “savages” were far nobler than Deliverance’s demented hillbillies. As indicated, 1987’s Hope and Glory was Boorman’s movie memoir of growing up during the Nazi blitz of London. 1995’s Beyond Rangoon starred this year’s Best Supporting Actress Oscar winner for Boyhood in this pro-human rights feature opposing Burma’s Rangoon goons. And so on.

Like Jean-Luc Godard, the 82 year old John Boorman is still going strong, but Queen & Country could, alas, be his cinematic swan song. Be that as it may, it is a well made, entertaining movie about the human spirit rising above military madness and depersonalisation in a quest for love and art.

People’s World

Next article – EU making NATO defunct?

Back to index page

Go to What's On Go to Shop at CPA Go to Australian Marxist Review Go to Join the CPA Go to Subscribe to the Guardian Go to the CPA Maritime Branch website Go to the Resources section of our web site Go to the PDF of the Hot Earth booklet go to the World Federation of Trade Unions web site go to the Solidnet  web site Go to Find out more about the CPA