Communist Party of Australia  


The Guardian

Current Issue

PDF Archive

Web Archive

Pete's Corner


Press Fund


About Us

Why you should ...

CPA introduction

Contact Us

facebook, twitter

Major Issues





Climate Change



What's On






Books, T-shirts, CDs/DVDs, Badges, Misc


Issue #1752      October 12, 2016

Tragic farce on Manus

A 28 year-old Iranian asylum seeker in Mike Compound in the Manus Island detention centre attempted to set himself alight on September 30. The man, who was one of those seriously wounded in the 2014 attack by locals and police on Mike Compound, sprayed himself with flammable liquid before using a lighter to try and set himself alight. Fortunately, other asylum seekers at the scene quickly intervened, preventing the fluid catching fire, and he was uninjured.

After security firm Wilson’s Emergency Response Team arrived, the asylum seeker was placed on high watch. The incident is one of the growing numbers of self-harm incidents on Manus Island, as the six month political crisis surrounding the centre drags on. The PNG Supreme Court order in April to close the centre have been ignored.

Bizarrely, a so-called “Communication Guide” issued to Manus prisoners by PNG Immigration on September 27 says that the closure of the centre “… will not be rushed.”

The asylum seeker is one of the group of around 30 who have consistently refused to cooperate with the refugee determination process. Despite the fact that this group of asylum seekers have never been interviewed, some of this group have recently been given a negative refugee assessment.

Australian Border Force has also cut the weekly allowance of 25 points that can be used in the detention canteen to buy phone credit, in an attempt to force this group of asylum seekers to attend an interview.

Tensions have been rising since the PNG and Australian immigration moved to tighten rules over the Manus detention centre despite a PNG Supreme Court ruling in April that it must be closed.

Refugees and asylum seekers from the detention centre are no longer allowed to visit or stay in the East Lorengau Transit Accommodation.

Immigration and [management contractors] Broadspectrum are again causing social upheaval, this time to force all double negative asylum seekers into Mike Compound. They have set a deadline of October 4 for the move. People with a positive assessment are expected to move from Mike to Foxtrot.

PNG immigration has warned that PNG police may be used to enforce the transfer between compounds. PNG police were involved in the 2014 attack on Mike Compound that resulted in the death of Reza Barati.

The restrictions are further steps to try and coerce asylum seekers to return to their home countries. But the restrictions also make a mockery of Australian and PNG Immigration claims that the centre is “open”.

Both Australia and PNG governments are panicking to try and pre-empt the PNG Supreme Court hearing on October 27 where an application for “Summary Judgment” will seek orders for the immediate closure of Manus and the return to Australia of all those refugees and asylum seekers who wish to do so.

“Rather than face its legal responsibilities, the Australian government is determined to try to keep Manus detention open and maintain the fiction that resettlement is possible in PNG,” said Ian Rintoul, spokesperson for the Refugee Action Coalition.

The PNG immigration letter to asylum seekers warns that non-refugees will face deportation but further legal action is possible in all of those cases and PNG Supreme Court injunctions prevent the removal of any asylum seeker who is attached to the Ben Lomai case*.

“The Australian government is trying to save face, and is doing everything it can to maintain offshore detention policies and bully the PNG government to prevent families being united, and prevent refugees finding a secure future,” said Rintoul, “The Turnbull government should stop the delaying tactics, stop obstructing the courts and bring all the refugees and asylum seekers to Australia.”

(* The Papua New Guinea Supreme Court is considering who has legal responsibility for hundreds of detained men after it ruled Australia’s processing centre on the island was unconstitutional and should close.)

Lawyer Ben Lomai – who represents a number of the detainees – says there has been no action by Australia or Papua New Guinea since the Supreme Court declared the processing centre on Manus Island unconstitutional in April.

The PNG government had said it would close the facility and ask Australia to find alternative arrangements for the hundreds of asylum seekers and refugees held there.

Mr Lomai says at the least, the Supreme Court is expected to say both countries are equally responsible.

He says Australia needs to do the right thing for the people it has been sending to Manus Island under a regional resettlement program signed with Papua New Guinea.

“We can’t enforce the order of the Papua New Guinea Supreme Court against the Australian government, but we are of the view that, morally, the Australian government should accept that position in law as interpreted by the Papua New Guinea Supreme Court and they should be able to abide by that, especially where they have relations with the PNG government and to which such an offshore program has been established on Manus Island. So, in a way, they should take some more responsibility. Morally, they are obligated, in our view.”

Next article – Baryulgil man takes action over asbestos

Back to index page

Go to What's On Go to Shop at CPA Go to Australian Marxist Review Go to Join the CPA Go to Subscribe to the Guardian Go to the CPA Maritime Branch website Go to the Resources section of our web site Go to the PDF of the Hot Earth booklet go to the World Federation of Trade Unions web site go to the Solidnet  web site Go to Find out more about the CPA